Defendant in ’06 murder case sent to mental hospital

ROSEVILLE — Eric Martin Minchak, accused of using a knife in the death of a woman at a Roseville gas station in 2006, has been placed under the conservatorship of Placer County and sent to Napa State Hospital for continued mental health care.

Minchak, 31, of Pennsylvania has spent the last three years in Atascadero State Hospital after a judge ruled that he was mentally incompetent to stand trial on charges of robbery and the first-degree murder of the victim.

Prosecutor David Broady of the Placer County District Attorney’s Office said that defendants who are declared mentally incompetent to stand trial can be held for a maximum of three years in a state hospital.

“At the end of those three years, the person would either have to be released or held civilly under a conservatorship, which means that the government steps in on the person’s behalf to provide for his care,” Broady said.

Broady said the action taken Jan. 13 by a conservatorship judge in Placer Superior Court “ensures the public safety by keeping the defendant locked up.”

The Placer County Public Guardian, under the office of the county’s Health and Human Services, has been appointed the conservator, Broady said.

Each year, Minchak, who is represented by the Placer County Public Defender’s Office, will be entitled to a hearing to determine if he should remain under the conservatorship, Broady said.
“If and when he is deemed mentally competent, he could be ordered to stand trial for the murder and robbery,” he said.

Broady said the latest action presents “a very difficult aspect” for the members of the slain victim.

“Unfortunately, there is no closure for the family because the case and the criminal charges against Mr. Minchak remain pending,” he said.

The victim, 45, was murdered on April 2, 2006, as she was pumping gasoline into her vehicle at a service station in Roseville.

Eric Martin Minchak

Defendant in ’06 murder case sent to mental hospital was last modified: January 10th, 2019 by admin
Categories: Placer

About Author

Press Intern

Penne Usher has been a bureau chief with United Reporting - Crime Beat News since May 2008. An award-winning journalist and columnist, she is an online content editor for the company's crime news website,, and is a freelance correspondent for Sacramento-area newspapers. She can be reached at